|
Altschuler & Somkin 2005 [19] (Score = 0.80**)
|
|
Research question(s)/Objective(s)
|
Yes
|
Described clearly and evident throughout the text
|
|
Study design
|
Partially
|
Not explicitly named; inconsistencies in subsequent data collection not evident
|
|
Study context
|
Yes
|
Setting is described
|
|
(Theoretical) frame of reference
|
Partially
|
Study objective does not completely follow the knowledge that is depicted in the introduction
|
|
Sampling
|
Partially
|
Described and reproducible; random sampling was performed until theoretical data saturation was reached; consent of women was obtained before the interviews began. Duration of study not mentioned.
|
|
Data collection
|
Yes
|
Reproducible
|
|
Data analysis
|
Yes
|
Categories, codes, and memos described; categories listed explicitly
|
|
Reliability
|
Yes
|
Second author verified formation of categories/assignment of codes by the first author; if there were discrepancies in the codes, they went back to the original material and found consensus
|
|
Conclusions
|
Yes
|
Results discussed; results of other studies are drawn upon as comparison
|
|
Reflexion
|
Partially
|
Possible influence of financial compensation were not reflected; recall bias listed as possible weakness of the study
|
