Model | PEG-2A+RBV vs INF+RBV | PEG-2B+RBV vs INF+RBV | PEG-2B+RBV vs PEG-2A+RBV |
---|---|---|---|
Random-effects pair wise meta-analysis | |||
Frequentist (DerSimonian-Laird) | 3.63(1.51-8.73) | 1.30(1.11-1.52) | 1.38(1.07-1.79) |
Frequentist (Hartung-Makimbi) | 3.60(1.56-8.34) | 1.35(1.11-1.64) | 1.38(0.36-3.24) |
Bayesian (weakly informative) | NA* | 1.36(1.10-1.73) | 1.38(0.94-2.22) |
Bayesian (frequentis informed) | NA* | 1.30(1.11-1.55) | 1.40(0.86-2.47) |
Bayesian (empirically informed) | NA* | 1.36(1.10-1.74) | 1.38(1.02-1.99) |
Random-effects MTC models | |||
Weakly informed variance models | |||
Homogeneous variance model | 2.42(1.75-3.60) | 1.53(1.19-2.03) | 1.58(1.18-2.26) |
Unrestricted variances | 2.11(1.40-3.57) | 1.38(1.13-1.79) | 1.50(1.06-2.53) |
Exchangeable variances* | 2.17(1.48-3.43) | 1.40(1.15-1.79) | 1.53(1.11-2.36) |
Consistency variances structure | 2.39(1.63-3.80) | 1.42(1.16-1.86) | 1.67(1.17-2.68) |
Moderately informed variance models | |||
Frequentist informed priors | 2.04(1.45-2.93) | 1.38(1.15-1.69) | 1.46(1.12-2.05) |
Empirically informed priors | 2.23(1.54-3.40) | 1.44(1.16-1.83) | 1.54(1.13-2.29) |