Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 3 List of all studies included in one of the two reviews

From: The art and science of study identification: a comparative analysis of two systematic reviews

Study Status Baxi Status Rosen Reason for exclusion / Failure to identify study Reason for omission
Armstrong 2000 Included Not identified Non-specific study topic Not identified: Non-specific study topic
Borelli 2010 Included Identified & Excluded (FT) No true control group Discordant interpretation of same eligibility criteria
Chan 2005 Included Identified & Excluded (FT) Outcomes Outcomes not measured
Chilmonczyk 1992 Included Identified & Excluded (FT) Data unavailable Systematic review methodology: Exclude reports with inadequate reporting
Culp 2007 Included Identified & Excluded (ABS) Population (pregnant) Review scope
Curry 2003 Included Identified & Excluded (FT) Outcomes Outcomes not measured
Davis 1992 Included Not identified Review scope Review scope
Ekerbicer 2007 Included Identified & Excluded (TI) Population (age) Review scope
Elder 1996 Included Not identified Search strategy: Search limits (age filter) Review scope
Emmons 2001 Included Identified & Excluded (FT) Outcomes Outcomes not measured
French 2007 Included Not identified Review scope Review scope
Hannover 2009 Included Not identified Review scope Review scope
Herbert 2011 Included Identified & Excluded (FT) Data unavailable Systematic review methodology: Exclude reports with inadequate reporting
Huang 2013 Not identified Included Search strategy: Source (PUBMED not searched) Not identified: Search strategy: Source (PUBMED not searched)
Hughes 1991 Included Identified & Excluded (FT) Outcomes Outcomes not measured
Kallio 2006 Included Identified & Excluded (FT) Data unavailable Systematic review methodology: Exclude reports with inadequate reporting
Kimata 2004 Included Identified & Excluded (FT) Data unavailable Systematic review methodology: Exclude reports with inadequate reporting
Lanphear 2011 Identified & Excluded (ABS) Included Goals Discordant interpretation of same eligibility criteria
Nuesslein 2006 Included Identified & Excluded (ABS) Outcomes Outcomes not measured
Patel 2012 Included Not identified Search strategy - Excluded by filter due to incorrect tagging Not identified: Search strategy: Filters, tagging, keywords
Philips 2012 Included Not identified Review scope Review scope
Pulley 2002 Included Not identified Search strategy: inadequate reporting by authors Not identified: Search strategy: Filters, tagging, keywords
Ralston 2008 Included Identified & Excluded (FT) Outcomes Outcomes not measured
Ralston 2013 Included Identified & Excluded (ABS) Outcomes Outcomes not measured
Ratner 2001 Included Identified and Excluded (FT) No true control group Mixed/Unclear
Schonberger 2005 Included Identified & Excluded (FT) Data unavailable Systematic review methodology: Exclude reports with inadequate reporting
Streja 2012 Not identified Included Search strategy: Source (PUBMED not searched) Not identified: Search strategy: Source (PUBMED not searched)
Teach 2006 Not included or excluded Included Unclear status Mixed/Unclear
Van't Hof 2000 Included Not identified Review scope Review scope
Vineis 1993 Included Not identified Search strategy - Excluded by filter due to incorrect tagging Not identified: Search strategy: Filters, tagging, keywords
Wahlgren 1997 Included Identified & Excluded (FT) Follow-up trial Mixed/Unclear
Wiggins 2005 Included Not identified Non-specific study topic Not identified: Non-specific study topic
Winickoff 2010 Included Identified & Excluded (FT) Outcomes Outcomes not measured
Woodward 1987 Included Identified & Excluded (FT) Data unavailable Systematic review methodology: Exclude reports with inadequate reporting
Zhang 1993 Included Not identified Search strategy: Search limits (age filter) Review scope