Skip to main content

Table 2 List of retained MTFs by KTA phase across all groups following Delphi-Round 2

From: Selecting implementation models, theories, and frameworks in which to integrate intersectional approaches

Model/Theory/Framework

Mean

Standard Deviation

KTA Phase: Identify Problem

 Iowa Model of Evidence-Based Practice to Promote Quality Care

4.57

2.31

 Knowledge Exchange-Decision Support

4.21

1.76

 Conceptual framework for context-based evidence-based decision-making

3.86

1.92

 Intervention Mapping Framework

3.71

1.98

 Promoting Action on Research in Health Services framework

3.64

1.74

 Quality Implementation Framework

3.50

1.65

 Ecological Framework

3.36

1.69

 PRECEDE-PROCEED

3.29

1.73

 Organizational Readiness to Change Theory

3.21

1.53

 Social Cognitive Theory

3.07

1.49

 Organizational Development Theory

3.00

1.80

 Organizational Theory of Implementation Effectiveness

2.93

1.38

KTA Phase: Assess barriers/facilitators to knowledge use

 Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR)

5.79

1.12

 Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF)

5.71

1.90

 Behaviour Change Wheel

5.57

2.10

 Ecological Framework

4.14

1.88

 Knowledge Exchange-Decision Support

4.07

1.73

 Promoting Action on Research in Health Services framework

4.00

1.71

 Plan-Do-Study-Act (PDSA) Cycles

4.00

2.00

 Theory of Planned Behavior

4.00

1.75

 Social Cognitive Theory

3.86

1.51

 Intervention Mapping Framework

3.86

1.70

 Health Action Process Approach (HAPA)

3.71

1.98

 PRECEDE-PROCEED

3.57

1.70

 Conceptual framework for context-based evidence-based decision-making

3.50

2.03

 Quality Implementation Framework

3.50

1.51

 Organizational Development Theory

3.43

2.03

 Iowa Model of Evidence-Based Practice to Promote Quality Care

3.36

1.95

 Organizational Theory of Implementation Effectiveness

3.36

1.60

 Organizational Readiness to Change Theory

3.00

1.71

KTA Phase: Select, tailor, implement interventions

 Behaviour Change Wheel (BCW)

6.36

1.08

 Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR)

5.79

1.31

 Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF)

4.71

2.16

 Intervention Mapping Framework

4.57

1.83

 Promoting Action on Research in Health Services framework

4.57

1.22

 Quality Implementation Framework

4.57

1.50

 Plan-Do-Study-Act (PDSA) Cycles

4.29

2.09

 Diffusion of Innovations

4.00

1.92

 Ecological Framework

3.93

1.77

 PRECEDE-PROCEED

3.79

1.97

 Health Action Process Approach (HAPA)

3.79

2.01

 Social Cognitive Theory

3.71

1.44

 Theory of Planned Behavior

3.57

1.60

 Iowa Model of Evidence-Based Practice to Promote Quality Care

3.43

2.03

 Organizational Development Theory

3.29

1.94

 Organizational Theory of Implementation Effectiveness

3.21

1.67

 Conceptual framework for context-based evidence-based decision-making

3.21

1.76

 Organizational Readiness to Change Theory

3.00

1.71