Table 3 Agreement of information on time since last screening in survey self-report and IHIE (Weighted)
From: Comparison of health information exchange data with self-report in measuring cancer screening
Screening Tests (Time since last screening) | Survey responses (1) | EMR (2) | Concordance- Gwet’s AC (95% CI) Benchmark scale for reliability (3) |
|---|---|---|---|
Colonoscopy n = 220 (SR = 1 & EMR = 1) |  |  | 0.53a (0.43,0.63) Moderate |
 < 1 yr | 60/220(27.27) | 73/220(33.18) | |
 > 1 yr- < 2yrs | 45/220(20.45) | 41/220(18.64) | |
 > 2yrs- < 3yrs | 35/220(15.91) | 35/220(15.91) | |
 > 3yrs- < 5yrs | 38/220(17.27) | 24/220(10.91) | |
 > 5yrs- < 10yrs | 42/220(19.09) | 38/220(17.27) | |
 >  = 10yrs | - | 9/220(4.09) | |
FIT test n = 11 (SR = 1 & EMR = 1) |  |  | 0.21 (-0.21,0.64) Fair |
 < 1 yr | 11/11(100.0) | 4/11(36.36) | |
 > 1 yr- < 2yrs | - | 2/11(18.18) | |
 > 2yrs- < 3yrs | - | 2/11(18.18) | |
 > 3yrs- < 5yrs | - | 2/11(18.18) | |
 > 5yrs- < 10yrs | - | - | |
 >  = 10yrs | - | 1/11(9.09) | |
HPV test n = 26 (SR = 1 & EMR = 1) |  |  | 0.48a (0.21,0.75) Moderate |
 < 1 yr | 9/26(34.61) | 8/26(30.77) | |
 > 1 yr- < 2yrs | 9/26(34.61) | 12/26(46.15) | |
 > 2yrs- < 3yrs | 3/26(11.54) | 2/26(7.69) | |
 > 3yrs- < 5yrs | 5/26(19.23) | 8/26(30.77) | |
 >  = 5yrs | - | - | |
Pap test n = 84 (SR = 1 & EMR = 1) |  |  | 0.58a (0.44,0.72) Moderate |
 < 1 yr | 36/84(42.86) | 36/84(42.86) | |
 > 1 yr- < 2yrs | 34/84(40.48) | 19/84(22.62) | |
 > 2yrs- < 3yrs | 14/84(16.67) | 11/84(13.09) | |
 > 3yrs- < 5yrs | - | 8/84(9.52) | |
 >  = 5yrs | - | 10/84(11.90) | |
Mammogram n = 157 (SR = 1 & EMR = 1) |  |  | 0.90a (0.86,0.95) Almost perfect |
 < 1 yr | 119/157(75.80) | 134/157(85.35) | |
 > 1 yr- < 2yrs | 38/157(24.20) | 6/157(3.82) | |
 > 2yrs- < 3yrs | - | 8/157(5.09) | |
 > 3yrs- < 5yrs | - | 2/157(1.27) | |
 >  = 5yrs | - | 7/157(4.46) |