Skip to main content

Table 1 Summary of simulation scenarios

From: Genetic matching for time-dependent treatments: a longitudinal extension and simulation study

Scenario

Description

Covariate distributions

Treatment assignment model

Correlations

-

Base case

x1, x2, x3, x4, x5\(\sim Bernoulli (0.5)\)

x6, x7, x8, x9, x10\(\sim N(\mathrm{0,1})\)

\(Logit\left({p}_{it}\right)= {\alpha }_{0, treat}+{\alpha }_{L}{x}_{1i}+{\alpha }_{M}{x}_{2i}+{\alpha }_{H}{x}_{3i}+\)\({\alpha }_{L}{x}_{4it}+{\alpha }_{H}{x}_{5it}+ {\alpha }_{M}({x}_{4it}{x}_{5it}) +\)\({\alpha }_{L}{x}_{6i}+\)\({\alpha }_{M}{x}_{7i}+\)\({\alpha }_{L}{x}_{7i}^{2}+\)\({\alpha }_{H}{x}_{8i}+\)\({\alpha }_{L}{x}_{9it}^{2}+ {\alpha }_{M}({x}_{6i}{x}_{9it}^{2}) +\)\({\alpha }_{H}{x}_{10it}\)

Autocorrelation:

x9, x10: AR(1) Pairwise correlation: ρ = 0

A

Correct functional form

Same as base case

\(Logit\left({p}_{it}\right)= {\alpha }_{0, treat}+{\alpha }_{L}{x}_{1i}+{\alpha }_{M}{x}_{2i}+{\alpha }_{H}{x}_{3i}+\)\({\alpha }_{L}{x}_{4it}+{\alpha }_{H}{x}_{5it}+\)\({\alpha }_{L}{x}_{6i}+\)\({\alpha }_{M}{x}_{7i}+\)\({\alpha }_{H}{x}_{8i}+\)\({\alpha }_{L}{x}_{9it}+\)\({\alpha }_{H}{x}_{10it}\)

Same as base case

B

Weak pairwise correlation

Same as base case

Same as base case

x9, x10: AR(1)

All covariates: ρ = 0.2

C

Strong pairwise correlation

Same as base case

Same as base case

x9, x10: AR(1)

All covariates: ρ = 0.7

D

Different autocorrelation structure

Same as base case

Same as base case

x9, x10: MA(1) ρ = 0

E

Non-standard normal covariate distributions

x1, x2, x3, x4, x5\(\sim Bernoulli (0.5)\)

x6, x7, x8\(\sim N(\mathrm{0,1})\)

x9, x10\(\sim N(\mathrm{2,1})\)

Same as base case

Same as base case

F

Non-normal covariate distributions

x1, x2, x3, x4, x5\(\sim Bernoulli (0.5)\)

x6, x7, x8\(\sim N(\mathrm{0,1})\)

x9\(\sim Poisson(2)\)

x10\(\sim Gamma(\mathrm{2,1})\)

Same as base case

Same as base case

  1. Description of all simulation scenarios ranging from Scenario A to Scenario F, exploring sensitivity of results to different functional forms of the propensity score, pairwise correlation across covariates, autocorrelation within covariates, and covariate distributions